Blog
Is Managed Transportation Right for You? 6 Things to Know
Managed transportation can take work off your team’s plate and give you more control of your freight. Here’s how to tell if it fits and which partner to trust.
Rising fuel costs, carriers turning down loads, freight bills nobody can explain: if that sounds familiar, managed transportation may be worth a look. This guide covers the signs it fits, what control you keep, and the questions to ask before trusting a provider with your freight.
Most shippers we talk to aren't looking to give up control of their freight. They're looking to get some of it back.
Fuel moves without asking permission. A carrier you've counted on for years turns down a load at 3 o'clock on a Thursday. The freight bill comes in over budget, and nobody can quite explain why. And the person responsible for all of it is usually responsible for three other things, too.
Managed transportation puts someone in charge of all of it: keeping fuel surcharges honest, lining up the next carrier before you need one, and explaining every dollar on the bill. That's the honest case for managed transportation. It isn't about handing off your freight. It's about handing off the work of running it to a team that does that work every day.
It's a big decision, and it should be. Here's what we'd want to know if we were sitting on your side of the table, starting with whether it fits at all.
What is managed transportation? Managed transportation is when a logistics provider takes over the day-to-day work of running your freight program — planning, carrier management, freight audit and reporting — while you keep the final say.
1. Signs your company needs managed transportation
Managed transportation isn't right for every shipper. If you have a transportation team with the time and resources to plan as well as execute, you may already have what you need.
Managed Transportation tends to make the most sense when a few of the following sound familiar:
• Transportation is everybody's side job. Booking, tracking and invoice questions are spread across several people, and no one owns the whole picture.
• Each location makes its own calls. Plants, warehouses or branches choose carriers and rates on their own, so nobody sees the combined spend or the chances to consolidate.
• Total freight cost is hard to pin down. Answering what you spend by lane or by customer takes days of digging, if it can be answered at all.
• Your team spends its time putting out fires. Most of the week goes to chasing late loads and disputing invoices, with little left for improving how freight moves.
If several of those describe your company, the rest of this article will help you judge whether a partner can actually close those gaps.
2. What drives your freight costs (beyond fuel)
Nobody controls diesel prices. When fuel climbs, it's tempting to treat the whole freight budget like the weather — something that just happens to you.
But fuel is usually the headline, not the whole story. A lot of money slips out in places you can manage: loads that ship half full when they could have been combined, routes built for last year's customers, accessorial charges nobody questioned, and fuel surcharges that have drifted away from the schedule you agreed to.
A good managed transportation partner starts there. Before anyone changes a carrier or renegotiates a rate, they should be able to show you where your dollars go, by lane and by customer, and which of those costs you can actually move.
“One of the ways we use the information NT Logistics provides is to track our accessorial charges at delivery points. If we're seeing excessive detention fees, we can contact our customer, work with them and find out if there's a better delivery time that would minimize those costs.”
— Dave Cole, COO, Willy's Fresh Salsa
Ask a partner: Can you show me my cost to serve by lane and by customer, and tell me which of those costs I control?
3. Who's responsible for how your freight performs over time
Every shipper has a carrier they trust. The trouble comes the day that carrier can't take the load. Capacity problems rarely give you much warning, and by the time freight is sitting on the dock, your options are usually fewer and more expensive.
Covering that load matters. But finding a truck is something any good broker can do. What sets managed transportation apart is that someone is responsible for how your whole program performs over time, not just whether today's shipment gets picked up. That ongoing work includes:
• Planning. Deciding how freight should move — which modes, which carriers on which lanes, where loads can be combined — and revisiting those decisions as your business changes.
• Coordination. Lining up backup capacity before it's needed, and watching shipments in motion so a late pickup or missed appointment gets caught while there's still time to act.
• Freight audit. Checking invoices against agreed rates and surcharge schedules before they're paid, so billing errors don't become the new normal.
• Reporting. Regular numbers on cost and service, by lane and by customer, that you can take to your own leadership.
• Ongoing improvement. Using that data to find the next change worth making, and following through on it.
“Before, it took days to get a price, and I never knew when shipments were getting there. Now I have my delivered pricing within an hour or two, and I never walk out of a meeting without the customer knowing what their cost is going to be. And we've never missed a single purchase order through all of COVID. I use that in every sales call I go to.”
— John Clark, VP of Sales, Willy's Fresh Salsa
Ask a partner: Beyond covering loads, who is responsible for improving my program over time, and how will I see that work?
4. What control do you keep with a managed transportation provider?
Handing off the work doesn't mean handing off the decisions. A good partner will make clear from the start where the line falls. In a well-run program, you keep:
• Your carrier relationships. If you have carriers who serve you well, a good partner should build around them, not replace them by default.
• Approval of significant changes. Changes to your routing, carrier mix or rates should come to you with the reasoning and numbers behind them.
• Your customer commitments. You set the service levels your customers expect. Your partner's job is to meet them.
• The final say on budget and priorities. Your partner runs the day-to-day; you decide what matters most.
Your team will still have a role. Someone will need to share order and shipment information, flag changes in customer requirements, and take part in regular performance reviews. The difference is that their time goes to decisions instead of chasing trucks.
For our customers, that role can be as simple as copying NT Logistics on each new purchase order. From there, NT plans the week's shipping and handles anything that comes up along the way, keeping their team informed.
All of this should be written down before the program starts: who approves what, who handles what, and how you'll be kept informed.
Ask a partner: Which decisions stay with my team, and how will that be documented?
5. How to tell whether a managed transportation provider deserves your trust
This is the part that gives most shippers pause, and it should. Turning over your day-to-day transportation means trusting someone with your customers' deliveries and your company's reputation.
Trust shouldn't be a leap of faith. It should be earned in ways you can check. Before you choose a partner, ask:
1. How do you qualify carriers, and how do you keep checking them after they're approved? How carriers are chosen carries real weight for everyone involved, so this isn't just paperwork.
2. Who is my day-to-day contact, and who is their backup? You want a dedicated team that knows your freight and your customers, not a ticket queue.
3. What will I be able to see, and how often? You should see your costs and performance as clearly as your partner does, not a summary once a quarter.
4. When something goes wrong, how will I find out, and what happens next? In trucking, something eventually will. What matters is who owns it and how quickly you hear about it.
A partner who's earned your trust won't mind any of these questions. In fact, they'll be glad you asked.
6. What the transition and first few months should look like
A good partnership shows itself early. You shouldn't have to wait a year to find out whether it's working. But first comes the handoff itself, and it should feel organized, not disruptive. A well-planned transition covers:
• Your shipment history. Recent shipment records and freight invoices give everyone the same starting picture of your lanes, volumes, carriers and costs.
• Your customers' requirements. Delivery windows, appointment rules and special handling — the things your team knows by heart — get written down so nothing depends on one person's memory.
• A clear handoff of responsibilities. Who books, who tracks, who handles exceptions and who approves what, agreed before the first load moves.
• Continuity for your freight. Shipments keep moving with the carriers and processes that work today while the new program is set up, and changes are phased in rather than made all at once.
How long that takes depends on the size and complexity of your network. A partner should be able to lay out a realistic plan for yours. Once the program is running, in the first few months you should see:
• A clear starting point. A baseline of where your costs and service stood before anything changed, so progress can be measured honestly.
• Regular reviews with real numbers. Not just a good feeling, but data you can take to your own leadership.
• Early warning and straight answers. Not every problem can be prevented. But you should hear about issues early, along with what's being done about them, instead of finding out from your customer.
• A short list of improvements. Specific changes, each with an owner and a date.
“In the first few months, a customer should be able to point to a few specific things that are better: a cost they finally understand, a lane that's stopped causing headaches, a report their own leadership trusts. If all they can say is that things feel smoother, we haven't done our job yet.”
— Chris Todd, President & COO, NT Logistics
Frequently asked questions
How is managed transportation different from using a freight broker?
A freight broker finds a truck for a load. A managed transportation provider is responsible for how your whole freight program performs over time, including planning, carrier management, freight audit, reporting and ongoing cost improvement.
Do I lose control of my freight with managed transportation?
No. In a well-run program you keep your carrier relationships, approve significant changes to routing, carriers or rates, set your customer service levels, and have the final say on budget and priorities. Your provider handles the day-to-day work.
How do I know if my company needs managed transportation?
It tends to fit when transportation is spread across several people as a side job, each location books its own carriers, total freight cost by lane or customer is hard to pin down, or your team spends most of its time chasing late loads and disputing invoices.
What should I see in the first few months of a managed transportation program?
You should see a baseline of your costs and service before anything changed, regular reviews with real numbers, early warning when issues come up, and a short list of specific improvements, each with an owner and a date.
Where to start
You don't have to hand over everything at once to find out whether managed transportation makes sense. The best place to start is usually the one part of your transportation that keeps coming back to bite you — the cost you can't explain, the lane that never seems covered, the carrier you're not sure about.
We've been managing transportation for shippers since 1999, and we've learned that a bit of data and an honest conversation go a long way. Share a sample of recent shipment data or freight invoices, along with the problem that's bothering you most. We'll review it and walk you through what we see: where the costs are coming from, what's worth fixing first, and whether managed transportation is the right fit. If it isn't, we'll tell you that, too.
Request your free transportation assessment →
Chris Todd is President and COO of NT Logistics, which has managed transportation for shippers since 1999. He has spent 25+ years in freight and logistics, including helping NT grow from a regional startup into a nationally recognized third-party logistics provider. Chris works with shippers to make their freight costs easier to understand and their transportation programs easier to run.
NT Logistics · All articles
